Mattituck Mushrooms

Absolutely love Mattituck Mushrooms! Anthony and Agat are truly salt-of-the-earth people — welcoming, generous, and deeply passionate about what they do. They always take the time to help identify mushrooms, answer questions, and educate the community with patience and genuine care. You can feel the heart they put into this place the second you walk in. They’re incredibly inviting to the public, open to walk-ins, and always willing to share their knowledge and time without ever making you feel rushed. That kind of authenticity is rare. And the mushrooms? The freshest, highest-quality mushrooms around, clearly grown and handled with real care and pride. Everything feels personal, thoughtful, and community-driven. Also, special shoutout to Yoda the dog, who makes the experience even better. If you haven’t visited yet, you’re missing one of the best local gems around.